Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 1:27:16 — 51.1MB) | Embed
“Shelter from the Storm” gives us a lesson in trust and loyalty while Supergirl does her best to save Sam’s mother Patricia, her daughter Ruby, and the world from the three-in-one WorldKiller Reign. Patricia dies, Ruby is scarred, and the world is still unsafe. It was not Supergirl’s best week, but this was one heckuva episode.
Since “Shelter from the Storm” is a song lyric from Bob Dylan let’s get some song lyrics going for our story titles this week…
“Mama,” Genesis
James and Lena are finishing up their macking from the night before when Reign rudely interrupts wanting to know where to find Ruby Arias. Lena kryptonite sprays her away but the ensuing DEO crime scene investigating leads to two conclusions–that J’onn and Supergirl need to go protect Patricia (Sam’s mama) and Alex needs to get to Ruby to protect her. The dynamic duo head to the Arias farm and Mama Arias tells the tale of how Sam always had this inner demon that needed to get out. When it went from her doodles in books to a full blown WorldKiller symbol on her wall Mama decided it was better to get rid of Sam rather than love to her a different outcome. “When you bury something, it comes back even harder,” she tells J’onn and Supergirl. Reign eventually comes and brings out all of her powers so our team is now up to speed on her trinity-ness. She is surprised to find Supergirl waiting on her but overcomes their trap and gives Mama the killing blow after Mama pleads with Sam to rise out of Reign. Back at the DEO, Mama makes Supergirl promise to communicate her love to Sam and Ruby as she fades out. Supergirl shares with J’onn that she’s not sure how she’s going to take on Reign. He reminds her that usually her heart is the key. In another part of this story J’onn is still battling with M’yrnn’s failing mind but Supergirl uses M’yrnn to figure out why he survived the White Martians instead of them killing him outright. Supergirl and J’onn figure out that he used the White’s own beliefs against them.
“Wind Beneath My Wings,” Bette Midler
Alex is set on going to Ruby’s hiding place, which Lena reveals is Lex’s now empty mansion. (Aunt) Alex gets to meet Mrs. Queller and she catches up with Ruby and wastes no time in lying to her that Mom is fine but is still unreachable. Ruby is not having the runaround yet Alex persists and eventually thinks she has Ruby settled with the lie of Sam’s being OK. Ruby “borrows” Alex’s phone and calls Sam which get’s Reign’s attention because she’s been listening above National City trying to locate her. Reign heads to the mansion and all kinds of homage heck breaks loose. (In a direct retelling of a Superman: The Movie deleted sequence) Reign drills herself down from one floor to the next, faces gunfire, fire fire, and ice and finally breaks the door down to get to Alex and Ruby. Supergirl and Re-Arrived Mon-El come on the scene and the brawl is on. Ruby gets in the fight only to find that Reign, having lost her facial mask in the tussle, is in fact Mom. Supergirl uses Reign’s own mantra of dispensing justice and wiping out sin to say that she can’t kill Ruby as she is innocent, and it works. With the use of Lena’s kryptonite, Reign is subdued and taken back to L-Corp for Lena to “find a cure.” Alex and Ruby reset with Alex promising not to lie again, even to protect Ruby from the worst.
“Love The One You’re With,” Stephen Stills
Blight has indeed been blotted out. The remaining tubular Legionnaires are all free of the blight sickness and the Legion are set to go Back to the Future! Brainy has a gift of 31st century Earth dirt for Winn and lifts him from a 1.0 to a 1.42 level intellect. Kara tells Imra that she is sure that Imra has been a huge influence of Mon-El becoming a better man. They say goodbye and then there’s the soulful goodbye between Kara and Mon-El, except that it’s only soulful on Mon-El’s part, and Imra keeps looking over her shoulder with serious dagger-eyes. Even later hearing that Supergirl and the DEO are 51% certain to defeat trinity-sized Reign, Mon-El is satisfied that his place is to return Saturn Girl to stave off intergalactic WAR! Imra totally lets him off the hook. She tell him to go back and help with Reign, not because the chances of winning increase to 88%, but because she needs “a man, a partner, that is fully with me.” If it’s his destiny then he should stay, if he returns then she’ll know he has no doubt. She says he’s done nothing wrong and has tried to bury his feelings and that he has acted honorably. So long, Legionnaires! We barely knew ye…
“Bad Girls,” Donna Summer
James hears that Patricia has bought the farm (too soon, I know) and tells Lena that she has to let Supergirl know that she can make kryptonite. Lena laughs almost in his face and says that Supergirl can’t think straight to see this as an alliance to take out Reign. Despite her better judgement Lena takes her kryptonite to the DEO and she is proven right in spades. Supergirl says she needs to be the only one in charge of kryptonite on Earth. Lena says Supergirl has a real God complex. It doesn’t end well. Later, Mon-El takes Lena’s kryptonite to Lex’s mansion, they take Reign down, and Supergirl later admits to Lena that her plan worked, she apologizes to Lena, and says that she trusts her. In one of the last scenes Kara is on an elevator and Lena gets on as well. They have a very tense exchange where Kara brings up that Lena is working with Supergirl to take down Reign. Lena says she’s only working with her because she has to. She tells Kara that Supergirl had James break into her private vault – which he didn’t do – (Oooooof) and that she tried to use Lena’s personal relationships against her – something like her mother would do (double Ooooooof). Kara looks hurt and embarrassed, and, well, she should.
Closing Thoughts
The last scene sets up our next episode with a Coville disciple taking a very important looking journal and getting chased out of the scene while she does it. This episode was impressive on many levels. We got Reign stopped on her own mission statement which is an inventive approach to take. The train wreck that is Lena/Supergirl/Kara is well on its way to destruction. We got another small reminder that Lena never feels accepted as we learn that she’s been living in a hotel for the past two years. Her character arc is arguably one of the strongest of this third Supergirl season. The acting was stellar as usual and we are exploring some real character conflict with personal choices being examined for their selfish motives. I am not a fan personally with the decision to have Mon-El return as I am for sticking with marriage no matter the circumstances (personal safety notwithstanding) but I understand that this relationship is a cornerstone for the show at this time.
News
Episode 19 – The Fanatical, Monday May 21 at 8:00E/7:00C on the CW
When a disciple of Coville’s escapes from what’s left of his cult, she gives Kara and James a journal that could hold the key to saving Sam; someone threatens to expose James if he doesn’t do what they ask.
Feedback
We want you to be part of the podcast! After a new episode airs, head over to our feedback page and drop us a quick line, or record a short voicemail, reacting to the events of the episode. What was interesting to you? What stood out? What did the episode do well or, perhaps, what did it not do well? We rely on your input to help round out our conversation and anticipate the opportunity to include your thoughts and theories!
Ooh dang John I didn’t even think about the NFL aspect at the time of hearing the news, yeah that’s not going to go great for ratings; I get they want to use an established show to lead into a new one hoping viewers will follow over but I hope they give “Supergirl” rope on the ratings as it were given they’d be going against such a powerhouse compared to their previous time slot. ALSO POINTS TO YOU FOR LIKING THE STEELERS! 🙂 The CW seems understanding about rating switches so that’s a plus but I hope they put it into practice and don’t fault “Supergirl” for the time slot.
As an original fan of “Charmed” I’m not sold on this remake yet, maybe the pilot is better than the poor promotional stuff it’s gotten so far, but that’s a fair question to ask – what happens if new shows go down during the schedule – are we going to see another shuffle to fill spaces like what happened when “Black Lightening” was introduced? John you aren’t filling me with positivity right now. Justina I like your counterpoints much better! 🙂 I definitely think CW would get backlash if they faulted the show for live ratings because they knew the competition number one, two it’s their only female title hero show (yes Sara is the captain on LEGENDS but she’s part of an ensemble no the series name holder) so it would seem arguably sexist to end it over live ratings when in comparison they continued the others and “Supergirl” has better ratings consistently this season than both shows airing on Mondays (ARROW and LEGENDS), and three again see ratings when in comparative slots – if you put “Arrow” or “Flash” in that slot they’d experience a drop too so be realistic about the series’s live numbers and consider all the data points for ratings and the talk of quality for the season because they have put them intentionally in a gray spot. “Supergirl” when it’s good can be great and arguably the best show on the network so I definitely hope CW has it go as long as “Arrow” at least, note I only say it’s arguably because I haven’t seen “Black Lightening” yet so I’m leaving room for a debate over the top spot – they’re a solid number two in my book though with my personal opinion being “Supergirl” is the best show on the CW.
I will say it does kind of speak to the faith of the CW in “Supergirl” that it picked them to head the slot as if they wanted the female shows connection they could have selected “Legends Of Tomorrow” to pair with “Charmed” as LEGENDS is a female heavy series too but they picked “Supergirl” so hopefully that’s a good sign.
I’m glad Clark wasn’t in this episode because he’s the one who got Kara on this over protective kryptonite kick in S2, in S1 she wasn’t crazy about the DEO having it but she understood it more than Clark – he’s the one who took it all from J’onn and got her kind of blinded. I get what Kara is saying to a point, but as Lena said lots of things can kill her but she’s not banning them and they do need it to stop Reign because Kara alone can’t so while understandable to a point her naivety has gotten old and I fault Clark so he can stay in Metropolis.
The way they wrote Mon only having to stay was ridiculous in my opinion; I’ll admit it wasn’t the worst written Mon story on the series but still it’s ridiculous to say “Supergirl’s future isn’t our future” when clearly you just established a straight path timeline so her future is in fact your future. It’s also unbelievable that Brainy would care enough to bug Winn’s dirt but not care enough to then go back and help them even though he likes them. And I’m sorry you’re telling me Irma’s father who made her get married basically to form peace is just going to be okay with Mon not showing back up even though he’s alive? I’m not buying it and can easily believe people in the future will be sadly paying for his absence. The only three who knew the Blight mission was complete were them so if Irma told her father her plan it’s not like he knew they had succeeded at a specific point so she has to be back before the next supper time if you will, it’s time travel they could have said they stopped anywhere in time for a vacation on the way back so that’s why the not immediate post return thus this idea that Mon needed to stay behind is just forced and again does nothing to improve his standing with me! It’s forced plots to give him moments that again really turn me off to the character; if they found more ways to naturally insert him into situations it might be one thing but saying he has to come on this adventure because there’s no kryptonite in Lex Luthor’s mansion is just bull. To be fair, there was a bit of natural flow to him being the one who could hold the box of kryptonite Lena gave them as J’onn was hurt and had they gone anywhere but Lex’s house it could have been more useful but because they were at LEX LUTHOR’S PERSONAL HOME to try and say he’s needed with it is harder to argue I feel; Kara and Alex had that under control because Alex could have fired the gun which totally would have had kryptonite in it because it’s Lex’s, yes Lena’s kryptonite was tailored to Reign but still it’s not enough for me to feel Mon had to be there especially as you have two other Legionnaires who could have hacked the traps (Brainy) or trapped Reign in a bubble because she’s had the best fight record against her so far (Irma) to help also. It’s just frustrating how they use Mon a majority of the time and the whole romance possibly doesn’t endear him either so again I really hope he goes to the future at the end of the season; the Legion can return as guests in S5 but three episode arc guests at best because you don’t want to over do them when they just had a full season about them.
YES TO MORE ODETTE AS SAM!!!
I disagree we needed Mon Justina, a lot was manufactured to make it him there because again Irma has the best fight record against Reign of any one currently and it’s Lex’s house 90% of it should have kryptonite at least in some form built into it.
Keep Alex Ruby’s J’onn unless Alex is going to marry Sam…which I am for if they want the adoption route.
Another good job Justina!
Wow John that Kidder-Reeves sign off was both depressing and sweet at the same time! A nice touch with the old music.