Podcast: Play in new window | Download (61.8MB) | Embed
[sc:mstop]
Welcome back to Maid of Steel! Thank you for joining us this week as we dive into the first episode of season two, entitled, “The Adventures of Supergirl”. If you’re anywhere near as excited as we are to have the show back, with new stories and new superhero craziness, then you are in the right spot! We are hoping that with Supergirl’s move to the CW, we’ll be seeing a greater variety in viewership. so if you fall into that category and are finding us for the first time, I’d like to encourage you to check out a couple episodes from our archive.
While Karen and I (Emilee) do not hold back on bringing up discussions from the previous season, which we acknowledge might be spoilery to new listeners, we do refrain from heavy discussion around what is coming up for the show. Based on news released about upcoming developments, and the show’s rich comic history, we know that just mentioning a character’s name can be a huge spoiler. We give you enough information, hopefully, for you to go investigate for yourself if that type of information is what you love! Plus, there is heavy discussion about all ongoing storylines on our Facebook page, so go check that out!
A Job For Both of Us
Superman and Supergirl teaming up for this premiere was about the most adorable thing that could have happened. The beginning of the first season had us all drowning in pronouns rather than any direct reference to Superman, and while it was awkward at the time (for Superman to be alluded to but never explicitly talked about) it made sense in terms of establishing this show as Supergirl’s show. Bringing Superman into the fold at this stage, after her character was developed and experienced an amazing season of self-discovery was appropriately timed.
Every time an iconic character like Superman (or even an iconic actor) is thrown into the mix, a show runs the risk of catering to that character. Storylines are devised to suit the person, instead of the person suiting the storyline. This is something I’m never a fan of, but I could not have been more pleased with the balance the writers sought while working through the Superman story. The actual plot of Lex trying to kill his sister not withstanding, I did not feel like this was a story for Superman. It was, for real, a job for both of them. Clark, with his years of experience and wisdom, was best utilized for his steady hand and keen eye. He brought stability to Kara’s life and, as a cousin and as a fellow superhero.
I also enjoyed the fact that the “feud” between Superman and J’onn wasn’t some obscure or abstract he-said, she-said thing. It was a really easy, albeit gray area, disagreement. J’onn keeps Kryptonite at the DEO as a means of defense, not against Superman (necessarily) but for the sheer fact that, as I get into a little bit in the next section, Kryptonians keep popping up. Superman thinks it’s dangerous and has too great a potential to fall into the wrong hands. If this was Smallville, Clark would probably hold a huge grudge and pout for a long time, but since this is Supergirl, they’ve written Superman to be a much more mature and even-headed individual… so that he can have this disagreement with J’onn while still respecting his leadership (to a degree).
The Man Who Fell to Earth
Our mystery guest of the week, the man who fell to earth, still has no official name. Yeah, if you go look him up on IMDb the character has a name. But I’m talking officially, like on the show. Clark doesn’t know him. Kara doesn’t know him. So I don’t know him. You might know him from the comics and, I’ll be frank, I cannot wait to know who he is and what his presence means here as well.
Remember that episode last season when Supergirl finally gives an interview to Cat Grant? When Kara began telling her story, that her planet was dying and her parents sent her to Earth to save her and look after her cousin, Cat gave her a bit of eye-rolling. Same story, different version. For a planet that exploded, killing an entire race, we have seen quite a few survivors. Partially due to the inherent intelligence of the Kryptonian race, partially due to the nature of space travel (in the fictional realm, of course), Kal-El survived, Kara’s aunt and uncle survived via The Phantom Zone, and now, perhaps, this mysterious man in the pod. Each case is legit as to why the individual survived, but it is a bit funny to think, “An entire planet exploded and everyone died. Except him. And her. And them. Oh, and him.”
Not that I’m complaining. Serious.
Cougar’s Comic Corner
The Brave and the Bold (1955-1983) #28
Featuring the first appearance of the Justice League of America! When Starro the Conqueror arrives on Earth intent on enslaving humanity, it’s up to the superheroes of the world to band together and defeat the evil alien! Also featuring the first appearance of Lucas “Snapper” Carr.
Buy on Amazon (Comixology)!
Feedback
To get in on the action and join the conversation, visit our feedback page! We try to make it easy on you to provide us with feedback in the method you most prefer. On the feedback page you can write an email, upload an audio file, or record a voicemail using the SpeakPipe widget on the page. Every week we read and listen to everything and the only reason we don’t include a feedback in the weekly show is if it came in after we began recording. So get in your thoughts before Wednesday at 6 p.m. Eastern! We record every week there is a new episode!
Links
- The Last Children of Krypton (Season 2 Episode 2 Promo)
- Extended Promos for Episode 2
- Every Superman and DC Comics Reference on the Supergirl Season 2 Premiere (via Den of Geek)
- Tomorrow’s Legends A Legends of Tomorrow Podcast
The bat bit was HILARIOUS! I agree with Emilee, as a hardcore viewer I was “Eh” about this episode; there was some good bits for sure but others were glaringly frustrating to me. I took Alex’s line of “Your cousin is amazing.” more as Alex teasing Kara because she knows that feeling Kara is experiencing given she’s constantly feeling like the Kara in that situation when it comes to Eliza so it was more her teasing Kara than actually falling for the idea of Clark/Superman like Winn and Cat did. I personally didn’t get the feeling Alex was depressed this episode, she was certainly more snarky given her more comfortable relationship with Jonn, but I didn’t get depressed from her this episode. Again I agree with Emilee, given this is the next day the whole Jimmy/Kara break up feels really inorganic especially seeing how much time in S1 they spent building it up; I’m fine with them breaking them up because they can’t have the number one couple together so soon arguably but I would have thought they’d been together for a few episode at least before the split…her relationship with Adam lasted longer than hers with Jimmy and Adam was only in like two episodes! It’s a lot of telling versus showing that brought my rating for this episode down, hopefully as the season progresses we’ll get more seeing instead of telling for character plots.
I have to say I’m not thrilled about the Jimmy rumors personally. I’m REALLY hoping Kara’s reporting tactics differ from Clark’s because again Kara is not Clark. Nice to hear Max is coming back for a few episodes, he’s a rear villain for the series; while I don’t want them together romantically I hope we’ll get some Alex-Max banter moments. It’ll be interesting to see who John Barrowman plays on “Supergirl” because I have to say I’m not a big Malcolm fan. I’m sure Chyler had a blast with the stunts this episode; I agree Alex kicking butt is awesome! π
Any Maggie Sawyer comic recommendations coming for episode 3 Karen?
I agree again about James/Kara; however if Jimmy and Kara are done can we see her with Adam again because they had some great chemistry also, unsurprising given Melissa’s and Blake’s relationship? I think it’s the cape connectors that make Superman’s suit feel weird…that and the belt combo; it’s not a horrible suit but next to Jonn’s and Kara’s it’s not that awesome either…I’d rather it been more “Man Of Steel” like or even taking after old versions but updating it but there’s just something off about his suit next to the others – again it’s okay but not my favorite. Emilee watch “Archer” it’s hilarious! You can watch “Archer” while Karen watches “Sky High” before Lydna’s appearance in episode 3 and then you can tell you can tell each other, and us if you’d like, about your experiences because seriously good things.
Again it’s good to have you guys back.
Blog post thoughts…
“Superman and Supergirl teaming up for this premiere was about the most adorable thing that could have happened.” – that’s only because Kara and Alex haven’t officially done it yet. π